Mel
Desmoines,#2Author of original report
Sat, January 07, 2012
I want to thank you for this information and I will follow thru with it. My last credit score was 780 and I don't think that is so bad so I will follow up with some letters.
Robert
Buffalo,#3Consumer Suggestion
Fri, January 06, 2012
It was no doubt, because when I received my bill on line, I would always pay it in full, never made payments, never ever late. They couldn't make money off of me.
They WERE making money off you. Credit Card companies charge vendors a FEE every time you make a purchase with a credit card. VISA charges about 4.25%-this is called a VENDOR'S FEE. The credit card company gets this fee regardless of how or when you pay your monthly CC bill. They cancelled your card for some OTHER reason.
This is why they closed our account.
No it wasn't. We'll get to that in a moment.
When I called about it, the lady was really nasty to me for no reason and told me to do what I wanted with the card because the account was closed due to a report.
Let me repeat that last part; "...the account was closed due to a report."
THIS is the reason the account was closed. If you want to know what information caused them to close it, you are entitled to that knowledge by a Federal Law called The Fair Credit Reporting Act. Closing the account is ADVERSE ACTION by the creditor and the FCRA states that they must inform you IN WRITING, as to what the ADVERSE INFORMATION was that compelled them to close the account. FAILURE to comply with this requirement of the law is ACTIONABLE and you may sue them for violating the FCRA in District Court.
If you really want to know why it was closed, you should send them a certified, return receipt requested letter that demands they comply with the FCRA and inform you of the specific information that compelled them to close the account. Be aware that many lenders will merely state something to the effect "we reviewed your credit report." This is NOT good enough for compliance with the law. The FCRA mandates that they furnish you with a written copy of the "adverse information" that they used as justification for closing the account. If they refuse to provide this written information to you, you should have no trouble finding an attorney to sue them on your behalf.
Additionally, because of this adverse action by them, you are entitled to a FREE printed credit report from Equifax, Trans Union, and Experience. You need to write a letter to these credit reporting agencies and demand a current copy of your credit report. The reports will be free because of this adverse action against you.
You should visit the FTC website, www.ftc.gov and download the Fair Credit Reporting Act. Give it a read and you'll easily find the mandates I'm telling you about. If you have any questions, just ask.
Good luck in the future.
Mel
Desmoines,#4Author of original report
Fri, January 06, 2012
I love american express anyway. Glad for the information from you.
Flynrider
Phoenix,#5Consumer Comment
Fri, January 06, 2012
My point was that banks make money on credit cards even when you pay the balance in full (otherwise they wouldn't do it). Your assumption was flawed. The more likely explanation is the one I noted, and that is regularly done at all banks.
Mel
Desmoines,#6Author of original report
Fri, January 06, 2012
I am glad that you are not having problems with the credit cards from the banks. I also have 2 other cards that I pay in full when I get the bill and they never give me a problem. When the Merrick card was issued, my score was a mear 650, not horrible but not that good. The other banks have no problem with me paying my account balance off each month. I am glad that Merrick bank is good to you.
Flynrider
Phoenix,#7Consumer Comment
Fri, January 06, 2012
" It was no doubt, because when I received my bill on line, I would always pay it in full, never made payments, never ever late. They couldn't make money off of me. This is why they closed our account. "
You seem pretty sure about that. If you knew the mechanics about how banks make money on credit cards, you'd probably have a different reason. I have three credit cards that are always paid in full every month. The oldest account I've had for 23 yrs., the youngest account I've had for 10 yrs. In all that time, I've never had an account closed because I paid in full. In fact, the three different banks did make money through my use of the cards. Your assertion that this particular bank didn't doesn't hold water.
The more likely reason is that the bank tightened its risk assesments and due to your credit, you no longer qualified for a line of credit. You said yourself that your credit was not good a year ago. Banks change their risk profiles on revolving credit accounts all the time. The agreement you had with them allows them to do this whenever they want to. It also does not guarantee that they will extend you credit for any given period of time. All card issuing banks operate the same way. It's not a ripoff. They get to decide who has access to THEIR money.