;
  • Report:  #290895

Complaint Review: Circuit City - Nationwide

Reported By:
- Wrentham, Massachusetts,
Submitted:
Updated:

Circuit City
Nationwide, U.S.A.
Web:
N/A
Tell us has your experience with this business or person been good? What's this?
Back at the end of July I purchased a Toshiba A215-S4807 laptop. Since purchase it has yet to make it through a single day without numerous blue screen of death errors or similar crashes. I have contacted the store where I purchased the laptop several times but I have been told that this is a Toshiba issue not a Circuit City one.

The laptop has spent several weeks in our local Toshiba service center where it has had the system board replaced twice among other tweaks. Still, not a single day goes by without multiple crashes. The OS has been reinstalled 3 times (once by the service center) & I have spent countless hours installing / removing / updating software. The errors cover hardware & software and change daily! It's like playing my kids Wack-a-mole game . I have been told it is a hardware issue by Microsoft & a software issue by Toshiba.

A working laptop that allows uninterrupted access to e-mail and the internet along with the ability to work on Office documents without having to go through hourly restarts & outright crashes does not see like an unreasonable request!! After 5 months of effort it is obvious that we are going to need to purchase a new laptop.

This unit is obviously a total piece of junk. From my web searches it seems that there are many others who have had similar experiences with both Toshiba & CC. The new laptop will not be a Toshiba nor will it be from Circuit City.

Faulty product while not necessarily Circuit City's fault does reflect poorly on them & their failure to stand behind their products & ensure that their customers are satisfied are sure ways to kill a business, especially a struggling one.

Dear Mr. ####:

Thank you for contacting this office with regards to the multiple repairs to the Toshiba laptop purchased in July 2007. It is unfortunate that the laptop has been problematic for you.

I have reviewed the letter you sent as well as the laptop purchase. Your laptop purchase did not include an extended warranty offered through Circuit City. The laptop has a 12 month limited warranty through Toshiba. We are unable to repair or replace the laptop as the warranty is through Toshiba. We recommend that you continue to work with them for any needed repairs.

We do stand behind the products we sell by offering a 14 day return guarantee on computers such as yours. After the initial 14 days of the purchase, any repair issues are referred to the manufacturer. While we anticipate your disappointment with this decision, Toshiba will make the final decision as to the repair or replacement of your laptop per their warranty terms and conditions.

Sincerely,

Marilyn Pando

Marilyn Pando

Executive Response Specialist

Office of the Chairman, President and CEO

Circuit City Stores, Inc.

Phil

Wrentham, Massachusetts

U.S.A.


5 Updates & Rebuttals

Phil

Wrentham,
Massachusetts,
U.S.A.
Toshiba finally bought back the laptop!

#2Author of original report

Tue, August 26, 2008

After over 10 months of "testing" and harassment of anyone I could contact at TAIS they used their "buy back program" to reimburse me for the laptop. I'm now very happy with the 2 Gateways I purchased from Best Buy.


Richard

Greer,
South Carolina,
U.S.A.
hmmmm

#3Consumer Comment

Sun, December 16, 2007

alright phil i'll play your game with you. 1. if circuit city did not accept the return before the 14 day period, then that store happened to be staffed by a bunch of idiots. i'll give you the benefit of the doubt, but only a slight benefit. 2. for the first year, if it was manufacter damages, yes it goes to toshiba, but toshiba will only cover what they think they caused, if they think you caused it, they are going to throw it right back on your lap and tell you stfu 3. by this point, tell toshiba you want a new laptop...its the third freaking time now and i would have gotten a new one from them, i dont care how many non-english speaking reps you have to talk to, ask for a supervisor that speaks english and you will get somewhere, if i can pull a new laptop out of hp with 2 phone calls, its not that hard for other companies, you just have to say the right things and finally my pet peeve of all, everytime im standing in line at customer service and hear a customer say it, i want to rack them on the back of the head with a broom handle, IT IS NOT CIRCUIT CITY'S PRODUCT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! best buy,now closing comp usa,office max,staples and every stinking electronics store carry the toshiba laptops. just because you got a crap laptop from toshiba dosent mean you shun circuit city. you gunna go shun every store that sells toshiba? hell you wont even have a place to buy a computer at anymore much less get parts from china and build it yourself....oh crap thats toshiba area too! only reason you should have a problem with circuit city is if they really didnt return it in the 14 day period, which as i said, if they didnt are a bunch of idiots working at that store in particular. the store in my area replaced my laptop three times till i got one that worked. do your research next time before you buy a product, thats why there are internet terminals in CC, also if you blue screened on day 1, you should have been back in that store 5 minutes after it blue screened, i would have.


Phil

Wrentham,
Massachusetts,
U.S.A.
Clarification

#4Author of original report

Sat, December 15, 2007

Just to be clear... 1. During the 14 day period I was told by CC to go through Toshiba. 2. The person at the Firedog counter told me that even if I had purchased the service plan it would still go through Toshiba for the initial one year period. 3. Toshiba have "serviced" it twice already without actually fixing anything. It is now on the way back for a 3rd attempt. 4. Again, the issues including the blue screen errors have been occuring since DAY 1. I wouldn't be this upset if it happened after a few months, nor would I expect CC to replace the laptop at that point. Another suggestion I 'm looking at at the moment is filing a dispute through American Express.


Terry

Rochester,
New York,
U.S.A.
Demand a replacement .

#5Consumer Suggestion

Sat, December 15, 2007

I've been there . First , file a complaint with your local Office of Attorney General Consumer Affairs , before your warranty runs out . ASAP . In your complaint on what you want to resolve the issue , write replacement PC of equal or better quality and value . ( I received a better PC - refurbished ,but better - and have had it for nearly 4 years now ) . The OAG will forward your complaint to the consumer contact person of the warranty Co. Be aggressively assertive , and demand a replacement . The warranty Co. that contacted me said they would not give me a new replacement , but a refurbished of equal or better quality . You have nothing to lose , and should get a 3 month warranty on the replacement .


Cc

Richmond,
Virginia,
U.S.A.
CC only has a 14 day guarantee

#6Consumer Comment

Sat, December 15, 2007

well i hate to say that Circuit city only offers a 14 day guarantee (unlss u buy the extra protection plan) not a lifetime guarantee....ur pc is undr manufactur warranty and i think u need to contact toshiba executive office for help....obviously CC executive office has told u about thier 14 day guarantee....if they replace your laptop anytime u want when u r hving problmes with it then i also want that guarantee along with alot of other consumers...a reailer can not make money like that. CC sells the product, provides u with 14 day guarantee nd even offers additional protection at an extra cost of course...so instead of contacting CC go to toshiba executive support....

Reports & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
Also a victim?
Repair Your Reputation!
//